21 Comments

Libertarianism essentially means freedom for the rich. If everyone can do whatever they want with minimal limits and obligations to consider the good of the collective, this ties personal freedoms to personal resources. Rich people can afford to do whatever they want — so they are more free.

It’s a bit like the inequality inherent to fines, but as an entire economic system. For a poor person, a fine is a deterrent. For a rich person, it’s a fee for breaking the law. Libertarianism seeks to present rights as unilaterally granted, rather than a constant negotiation of give and take that moderates society. It’s about what you’re entitled to, not what is good for the whole. Hence the extreme emphasis on property rights.

Rights are for the rich, when you’re a libertarian. Oh sure, the poor HAVE rights — after all, it’s about equal rights!!

But those rights turn out to be MUCH less equal if you don’t have the resources to enforce and utilise them.

Expand full comment

It's the same ploy with "free speech" - another executive order Donald J Trump signed on his first day in Office again.

The premise of free speech is "equality!" but the absolute free speech argument is a cover for them to openly broadcast e.g. anti-transgender and anti-climate views without inteference, in my opinion.

Expand full comment

Funny that I thought of Peter Thiel and his Queenstown bolt hole when I was doing my RSB submission, he’d be in before lunch. Always remember it was Jonkey who fast tracked his purchase of NZ citizenship, a bit like Seymour’s foreign investment moves… In their world everything is for sale. Love having Leunig in my life after many years, Larson next?

Expand full comment

We should also remember it was Peter Thiel who reportedly placed JD Vance as Trump's VP - and although he's been overshadowed now, it's a powerful position - especially if Trump dies.

Yes to Leunig and the Larson!

Expand full comment

If these clouds do have a silver lining it is that the hyper-egos of the tech oligarchs will eventually lead to conflict with each other and the orange one, even if they want the same thing.

Expand full comment

Their biggest concern is when society collapses, their wealth will not buy them privilege. Cued to a section from the 2022 BBC podcast, The Coming Storm Epilogue episode, about Thiel and the NZ connection.

https://pca.st/hraxjz2u?t=28m5s

Expand full comment

Your commentaries are superb. They need widespread reading . It’s time New Zealand woke up.in fact it’s overdue.

Expand full comment

Thank you for your clear powerful journalism. Hard work!!

Expand full comment

It is hard work, believe it or not - bringing out in words what is obvious to me in my gut is sometimes quite difficult for me, but I'm grateful for the kind words and support. Thanks B Insull and hope you're well :-)

Expand full comment

Revealing that Peters has dialed back on the sale of kiwi heritage assets to the US under the OIO Regs. The latest infamous decision is the sale of your personal information and mine by the sale of Vector's electricity meter-reading service. A guaranteed 3% of the household bill

Expand full comment

The first step to even the democratic playing field (and it maybe too late) is to stop money buying politicians.

Expand full comment

One of my early drum beating topics was the Independent Electoral Review recommendations which recommended a structure that would inhibit that. Of course, Paul Goldsmith buried that, but I hold out hope that one day there will be significant electoral donor reform - and I don't care what it's called - only that it's done.

Expand full comment

Someone who works for very wealthy Americans recently told me they all call NZ ‘apocalypse island’.

Expand full comment

So we are no longer a desirable life boat country for most, just the uber wealthy…

Expand full comment

So true KSJ. Plus we are exposed to the increasing conflict between Chinese and US expansionism. NZ could save billions by working as a Pacific Islands leader including remedying the damage to Samoa by HMNZS Manawanui as a priority

Expand full comment

Absolutely agree Tui. So sad we are followers of failed policy…. So much talent here we could be world leaders, if the scum didn’t rise to the top.

Expand full comment

That was Winston, KSJ :-)

Expand full comment

Soooo… Trump is wanting to close the borders and hike tariffs because Canada and Mexico are letting drugs into USA, but meanwhile he pardons the creator of Silk Road, which is a platform for, among other bad things, illegal drugs. Right…

Expand full comment

Yes I believe that platform's main thrust is trading (buying and selling) illegal drugs - and the builder of it is knee deep in crypto and has untold wealth waiting for him.

Expand full comment

Fuck america! And rich fucking americans!

Expand full comment

I do know a lot of good Americans and they fight hard, but the system is really geared towards the mega elite - while they unironically and successfully label others, such as non-co-operative academics, as the elite.

Expand full comment