44 Comments
User's avatar
Ria Roberts's avatar

I think it's a low bar, when a PM talking to their friend's kids is supposedly a sign of being special.

And it's concerning that the PM's friend has been awarded a major contract that sidesteps public health rights.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Indeed, and let's face it - that's not who Luxon really is either. Cecilia Robinson seems to be confused.

https://mountaintui.substack.com/p/christoper-luxon-flies-high

Ryan Ward's avatar

How nice to check on kids flying alone. Too bad he does fuck all for any other kids, let alone workers, women, and Māori. Give me a break.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

But it was said with such sincerity, and they appear to be very close and affectionate with each other as families and friends ?

Ryan Ward's avatar

I have no doubt they sincerely believe they are good people. And that all of the bottom feeders just need to try harder to take advantage of the opportunities they have been given. It’s an insidious normalisation of blaming the victims of capitalism for their own misery.

Keith Simes's avatar

Reading Cecilia’s fawning fairy tale made me want to puke! So I got in touch with a digital health provider, ie I put my fingers down my throat

KSJ's avatar

lol!

Peter Olsen's avatar

Funnily enough I had the same response.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

It seems this article has illicited many health related reactions!

Stu McGregor's avatar

I have to admit that rehumanising politicians is a good thing to do and within family friend circles, seeing him as a good fella is fair and reasonable… it would be weird if he didn’t say hello to the kids. And it’s true Luxon shouldn’t have to apologise for his success.

The disconnect seems to be that he can’t see the plight of kids outside his circle as human. They aren’t a problem to be solved, they are humans that need attention. It’s only natural we would dehumanise someone who is dehumanising at scale.

I’m reminded tho that if I dehumanise another human, I am in fact part of that system too.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Absolutely.

One of the topics I've written about is the mystery of Tend Health and Health NZ making them a PHO: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0161zyZAWI

It's only because of that topic that I even pay attention to these folks, because open mysteries bug me and I don't think anything extra has been revealed since that 1News report... so it's on my mind.

However, on this topic and humanisation, yes - I think it's very fair what you say - and what's clear is this very deep and friendly relationship between Robinson and Luxon - something I didn't know about before.

She writes very well BTW - very clearly and in a way that suggests sincerity for those she likes...and her praise for Luxon is effusive and unmitigated.

Ditto Anna Mowbray in her support for her friend - these are all people who look after their own and support each other.

It would be touching were it not for how some figures like Luxon treat the bottom feeders and people he appears to deem below him - that's most people who aren't wealthy and sorted.

Also I recall Cecilia Robinson write that she does not believe healthcare is underfunded in NZ - this is very significant as it goes against what public health professionals say.

And her privatised healthcare tries to fill a gap - offering telehealth to public patients where she receives significant govt funding and $80 or so on top from patients.

i.e the success of these privatised PHOs do have a relationship to the well being of ordinary Kiwis.

So there is a lot of interrelationship in my view - including, the question of how we humanise people who may not in turn humanise us...

That said you're right - we are either able to or we are no different.

Thanks for your wisdom, Stu.

Robin Capper's avatar

Every cent directed to privatised PHO's is theft from the public system.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

This 100% and what the Bagshaws said on Q&A the other day.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAKfaIFYuy0&feature=youtu.be

Susie Vincent's avatar

I have no doubt that this unreasonably entitled bunch give each others’ children a lot of TLC, and that among them they are very huggy and kissy. I am sure this is genuine. Meanwhile, the notion of the greater good is I think a mystery to them all.

The proceedings around the helicopter pad (Orsman, NZ Herald a few weeks ago) were appalling. 1300 opposed, 100 in favour, yeah that’s a good ratio to merit approval, on the basis that all the environmental and societal impacts described are, of course, overstated and catastrophising.

This philosophy of ‘if it’s not nailed down, then let’s scoop it up and eat it’ - - this notion of swanning about, ostentatious wealth and unrestrained self-interest - - reminds me of how in the US, 18-25 year olds went crazy about the Kardashians, a bunch of vapid, greedy and self indulgent hedonists. Is this a disease? Grrrr.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Cecilia Robinson wrote that she does not believe healthcare is underfunded in NZ -against the advice and views of all public health professionals I've seen.

https://www.tend.nz/blog/cecilia-robinsons-mission-to-revolutionise-healthcare

Her business, like other privatised models, are now receiving significant taxpayer funding on top of patient fees...

I personally don't mind people being wealthy, successful, famous etc. - I do raise my eyebrows when it's done in ways that I don't understand

Susie Vincent's avatar

Totally agree, no problem with wealth or fame. Thinking Bob Geldof, still worth around $150 million after all these years. Personally, I feel wealth and power are assets that we don't entirely own: sure, get a decent house and car, but these are privileges that life requires us to use for universal wellbeing. It's called noblesse oblige, and it's got lost in the wash.

Rather, people are credited for getting rich and 'sorted' as a virtue when most wealth is inherited, and most of the rest of it comes from shareholders. Also, Tui, I echo your sane questions on this Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/newzealand/comments/1lns09m/venerating_cecilia_robinson_from_my_food_bag_tend/

In that post it was also noted how C Robinson wrote such lovely things about Luxon and Simeon Brown before oh so surprisingly getting this hugely lucrative PHO status for Tend, and how "some Mum and Dad investors lost 97% of their investment" (in Robinson's My Food Bag).

Cheryl Johnstone's avatar

And at the end of the day the noise of a helicopter is just like the sound of a car. It's. Ike a damned Tui add.......yeah right. No problem at all.

Susie Vincent's avatar

Or a lawnmower on a sunny afternoon, eh.

James Wilkes's avatar

Absolutely zero surprise MT. I’m actually lost for words here. I mean genuinely lost for words that would provide any meaningful traction to my thinking on this issue. I will in passing just say: here he is again. Luxon is like a Jack-in-a-box who just keeps popping up in all the wrong ways in all the wrong places. And I totally get the Swedish connection here. It’s called surströming, the process of salting small Baltic herring and allowing them to ferment for several months, sometimes over a year in barrels or cans. The fermentation results in a strong, pungent odor that some describe as rotten, musty, or even fecal. Yep, that’s what I’m smelling, can you smell it too? Something is definitely off.

On a brighter note, to allow my imagination free rein and to rest back some control from these disgraceful human beings, I’ve gone into full-fiction mode. My next Substack post is going to play with this idea for fun. In my imagination, I can achieve outcomes I could only dream about in the real world. Yes, correct, I have decided to travel to another dimension in my homemade tardis to make some proactive changes. Let’s get started, here is an excerpt:

“The revolution in New Zealand wasn’t the only uprising on the planet. In 2029, discontent boiled over. Inequality, the dry tinder of revolution finally ignited across the democratic world. Its incandescence mirrored the Arab spring revolution in Tunisia in 2010. The uprising was bloody, amplified by years of suffering and struggle and frustration. Vulture Capitalists were specifically targeted and singled out. Retribution was immediate. The minions of the billionaire Think Tanks, which included politicians, elites, and their enablers all faced the fury of the mob and mob justice was served.”

Don’t worry….there’s more. I’m still playing around, but I’m going to have some fun. Standby.

Enjoy your weekend MT. Thank you for soldiering on, we need to keep shining a light on all this because it isn’t right.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Fiction. I like it.

These times often feel like "life is stranger than fiction" so going back the other way seems well advised.

Cheers, James - have a great weekend too,

MT

Janine McVeagh's avatar

Tim Winton's latest book, Juice, deals brilliantly with these themes.

James Wilkes's avatar

My fave writer and a fellow Western Australian Janine. ✊

James Wilkes's avatar

My ‘Kiwi’ version of a dystopian world is coming….😁

Ange Boland's avatar

Awwww, so sweet… 🤢

So is that how/why Tend Health got their contract, and in record time?

More corruption 🤬

Mountain Tūī's avatar

It reminds me of the mystery I wrote about regarding Health NZ and Simeon Brown saying he had nothing to do with it.

Note: I'm not suggesting any wrong doing at all by anyone - I still don't understand what is happening and I think Simeon and Health NZ need to make it clear for us.

Ange Boland's avatar

Every day they insult our intelligence…

Judith Paulin's avatar

Very revealing!!

Korimako Song's avatar

Soon the ferries will stop and the only way to get to Waiheke will be by helicopter... At least they have a vineyard there.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Nothing against anyone on the island of course, but of interest here is proximity of Luxon and Robinson

Judith Paulin's avatar

Yes I found thatVERY revealing …..

Paul Singh's avatar

Nooooo.... send a rescue chopper for Bernard Hickey and Lynn Grierson first please.

Korimako Song's avatar

Good point. Maybe they have their own boat. Maybe I’m too old to comment really. Haven’t been to Waiheke for over 20 years.

Robin Capper's avatar

Maybe why Bernard does so much swimming, training for the lack of ferries?

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Can only assume that's the sign of a fit person!

Mike Bennett's avatar

I feel so nauseous that I need a lie down

KSJ's avatar

Thanks Tui, had to stop drinking my coffee while I read Cecilia’s sycophantic drivel 🤢.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Understood. I've long wondered about this topic...

Nick Rockel's avatar

She gives off serious Multi-Level Marketing vibes, is thick as a brick, based on hearing her interview, and should be nowhere near our health system.

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Writer's touch - thanks Nick for the summary!

Cindy's avatar

🤔 It is entirely possible/probable that these "wealthy & sorted" friends (?) have genuine regard for each other - they have no reason NOT to ⁉️ They haven't been restructured out of their jobs, laid off from their careers serving the public on public service pay, subjected to the unimaginable stress of being a nurse or Dr & being so under-resourced that seriously unwell patients are being treated on plastic chairs in a corridor because there is not enough staff to manage the beds on the ward that would otherwise take them (I've personally been there with someone 3hrs after being "discharged" but still occupying the bed as personnel doing more urgent things than signing papers & wheeling a wheelchair!) They can AFFORD to put their kids on an airplane to wherever while mothers & fathers who are unemployed don't know how the next meal, or pair of shoes, or Drs visit will be paid for. Or they won't be a pensioner sleeping in their car in the freezing winter because they can't afford somewhere to rent, IF they could find somewhere suitable.

It is easy to find the time to write sycophantic 🤮 about your famous "friend" & lobby to get a heli-pad to avoid rubbing shoulders with the general public or being inconvenienced by "normal" transport problems in getting to and from your privileged house to live your privileged life 🤷

Sorry, but this echelon of society leaves me cold 🤬 There ARE wealthy & sorted people in the world who USE their wealth (& in many cases celebrity, but also many who seek no recognition) to fund projects & schemes to save & improve the lives of the less fortunate, and keep in touch with reality rather than live this artificial lifestyle of the rich & ignorant - which "Olivia's dad" has proven day after day to be (ignorant that is 😱)

Mountain Tūī's avatar

Many "successful" people rely on taxpayers money for building wealth but seem to forget it too quickly

Cheryl Johnstone's avatar

The Bagshaws are a wonderful example of the people you speak of Cindy.

Marlene's avatar

I just wanted to vomit when I read that article.

James Wilkes's avatar

Yes Susie it is a disease and it has riddled humanity since Caligula was a boy.