High Court has ruled that Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith unlawfully appointed Human Rights Commissioner Stephen Rainbow and Race Relations Commissioner Melissa Derby. Both failed the HR processes
Everything you say is true. The best thing about this CoC is consistency - they ALWAYS ignore proper procedures/processes, preferring to just do the wrong thing
There are NO consequences though! It should mean that the Minister is immediately stood down and the two appointments annulled... but has that happened?
Yes, but both keep their jobs. Goldsmith was pandering to ACT and overlooked the advice. These are both important positions in our democracy but who the hell would take these two seriously?
This makes my blood boil, the election that got this CoC into power was bought and paid for by the rich brown noses from Auckland and now this CoC are preventing the democratic right of every kiwi to vote. I'm just too angry to continue.
"...Goldsmith pushed through the voter suppression law this week that will disenfranchise tens of thousands of Kiwi voters.
And it will likely boost National Party seats by 2-3, based on historical precedent."
I've said it before and I'll keep repeating it... If the Nats win the next election by one or two seats (the number usually re-allocated after 'Specials' are counted and Party percentages re-calculated accordingly), that government will be seen by many as illegitimate.
I've been considering this and it may be such a severe attack on the democratic process that Labour, Greens, and Te Pāti Māori should have no other option but to vacate their seats in the Debating Chamber during the 3 year term. They should set up a "Opposition-In-Exile" in another building to scrutinise the illegitimate govts actions.
This may be a radical step, but voter suppression demands radical solutions.
Perhaps a peaceful, non-confrontational, re-occupation of Parliament's grounds?
🤔 I think in the meantime we need to do everything we can to make that moot by, as suggested elsewhere, a Judicial Review, AND making sure everyone we know is enrolled & uptodate so they CAN vote even if this anti-democratic legislation holds for the coming election 🤷 The best revenge is revenge ⁉️ Kick the 💩🤡 out & put as many as possible out of a job altogether (one that WE pay for anyway...)
The High Court judgement is damning. In earlier eras of Westminster-style ministerial responsibility, an honourable Minister would have tendered his resignation. Unfortunately, we don’t live in those times.
Its unbelievable how much has been pushed through, despite huge amounts of expert and public criticism. The mainstream media are not calling any of this out, no wonder with far right wing Billionaire taking over NZME, then funding a law suit against TV1. I would really love to know why Jenny-May left Breakfast so suddenly? Told she wasn't allowed to speak Te Reo anymore? I follow a few American pod-casters, and what happening in USA is scary but the similarities with what is happening here is even scarier. The change in voting rules pure corruption in my eyes.
Yup, pretty much. It would be a brave MP to cross the flood or withold their vote. I'm thinking Tariana Turia, Marilyn Waring, and Jim Anderton, that spring to mind...
She voted with the National 🚫 Block to keep National in the Drivers 💺 Seat & keep her high Salary coming in & her Political Perks, compliments of the Kiwi Taxpayer to keep Con-vita afloat while she offshores all of the remaining Ancient Kauri in Northland. 😉
These actions need to be put in the public arena by the opposition parties - every day people need to be told about this.The coalition should not be allowed to get away with anything. This has been their modus operandi from day one and it has left us in this parlous state. Thank you for continuing to draw our attention to this. I have never written so many submissions in my life - to what effect!
🤬 So where is our pretend PM when one of his Ministers is found to have acted illegally TWICE in these cases ⁉️ (not to mention all the other dodgy stuff he is responsible for as Minister) Too busy playing fake-christian happy families for the cameras to do his actual job eh ⁉️
Aotearoa is, at the moment, broken. Deliberately. By money and its craven worshippers in the CoC. If these bastards get back in next year the brokenness will be permanent, but it is so hard to get our msm to report any of it.
Thank you for this column and alll of your columns Tui. I really really enjoy reading them.....you have kept me sane. I also really appreciate your readers and their responses,it's great to read comments from those of the same thinking.
Everything you say is true. The best thing about this CoC is consistency - they ALWAYS ignore proper procedures/processes, preferring to just do the wrong thing
Justice Minister. His head should roll.
I bet someone will 'be comfortable with' or 'is unaware of' it.
lol
There are NO consequences though! It should mean that the Minister is immediately stood down and the two appointments annulled... but has that happened?
Yes, but both keep their jobs. Goldsmith was pandering to ACT and overlooked the advice. These are both important positions in our democracy but who the hell would take these two seriously?
Exactly! Why are there no consequences?
This makes my blood boil, the election that got this CoC into power was bought and paid for by the rich brown noses from Auckland and now this CoC are preventing the democratic right of every kiwi to vote. I'm just too angry to continue.
"...Goldsmith pushed through the voter suppression law this week that will disenfranchise tens of thousands of Kiwi voters.
And it will likely boost National Party seats by 2-3, based on historical precedent."
I've said it before and I'll keep repeating it... If the Nats win the next election by one or two seats (the number usually re-allocated after 'Specials' are counted and Party percentages re-calculated accordingly), that government will be seen by many as illegitimate.
I've been considering this and it may be such a severe attack on the democratic process that Labour, Greens, and Te Pāti Māori should have no other option but to vacate their seats in the Debating Chamber during the 3 year term. They should set up a "Opposition-In-Exile" in another building to scrutinise the illegitimate govts actions.
This may be a radical step, but voter suppression demands radical solutions.
Perhaps a peaceful, non-confrontational, re-occupation of Parliament's grounds?
🤔 I think in the meantime we need to do everything we can to make that moot by, as suggested elsewhere, a Judicial Review, AND making sure everyone we know is enrolled & uptodate so they CAN vote even if this anti-democratic legislation holds for the coming election 🤷 The best revenge is revenge ⁉️ Kick the 💩🤡 out & put as many as possible out of a job altogether (one that WE pay for anyway...)
Thank you, MT – so good to have you back.
The High Court judgement is damning. In earlier eras of Westminster-style ministerial responsibility, an honourable Minister would have tendered his resignation. Unfortunately, we don’t live in those times.
Not a peep from Luxon either.
Then again, I didn’t expect one.
Its unbelievable how much has been pushed through, despite huge amounts of expert and public criticism. The mainstream media are not calling any of this out, no wonder with far right wing Billionaire taking over NZME, then funding a law suit against TV1. I would really love to know why Jenny-May left Breakfast so suddenly? Told she wasn't allowed to speak Te Reo anymore? I follow a few American pod-casters, and what happening in USA is scary but the similarities with what is happening here is even scarier. The change in voting rules pure corruption in my eyes.
I'd like to know how Judith Collins voted on the electoral reform bill.
Judging by the numbers voting FOR the Bill to be read a third and final time, she voted in favour:
"A party vote was called for on the question, That the Electoral Amendment Bill be now read a third time.
Ayes 68
New Zealand National 49; ACT New Zealand 11; New Zealand First 8."
Ref: https://www3.parliament.nz/en/pb/hansard-debates/rhr/combined/HansDeb_20251216_20251216_40
There are 49 National MPs in this current Parliament. Ms Collins is one of that 49.
They have to tow the party line. Truth.
Yup, pretty much. It would be a brave MP to cross the flood or withold their vote. I'm thinking Tariana Turia, Marilyn Waring, and Jim Anderton, that spring to mind...
Yes.
Having actual principles isn't very common.
They don't have to toe the party line. They can cross the floor.
Luxon insists that they do not cross the floor.
She voted with the National 🚫 Block to keep National in the Drivers 💺 Seat & keep her high Salary coming in & her Political Perks, compliments of the Kiwi Taxpayer to keep Con-vita afloat while she offshores all of the remaining Ancient Kauri in Northland. 😉
I am so glad Goldsmith has been pulled up over this; it was a stupid appointment.
We have such an incredibly poor government!
Pulled up yes but no real conséquences. Disappointing but entirely expected.
These actions need to be put in the public arena by the opposition parties - every day people need to be told about this.The coalition should not be allowed to get away with anything. This has been their modus operandi from day one and it has left us in this parlous state. Thank you for continuing to draw our attention to this. I have never written so many submissions in my life - to what effect!
Just awful.
Surprise! But what’s going to happen? Nada… 🤬
🤬 So where is our pretend PM when one of his Ministers is found to have acted illegally TWICE in these cases ⁉️ (not to mention all the other dodgy stuff he is responsible for as Minister) Too busy playing fake-christian happy families for the cameras to do his actual job eh ⁉️
Aotearoa is, at the moment, broken. Deliberately. By money and its craven worshippers in the CoC. If these bastards get back in next year the brokenness will be permanent, but it is so hard to get our msm to report any of it.
Thank you for this column and alll of your columns Tui. I really really enjoy reading them.....you have kept me sane. I also really appreciate your readers and their responses,it's great to read comments from those of the same thinking.
A very happy Christmas T.
And you Cheryl! I appreciate you being here and your always kind words. Happy Christmas and a Joyous 2026.